The Trouble with Sarah
Sarah Hartsfield's husband Joseph died in 2023 after being hospitalized in critical condition for hypoglycemia—a dangerous drop in blood sugar. Investigators would soon find a web of suspicious deaths in Sarah's past.
Aired: Jan 16, 2026 Genre: Crime DocumentaryCasts:Duration: 43m Rating: 0 Country: United States of America Production: NBC News, Peacock Productions
Seasons
Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 5Season 6Season 7Season 8Season 9Season 10Season 11Season 12Season 13Season 14Season 15Season 16Season 17Season 18Season 19Season 20Season 21Season 22Season 23Season 24Season 25Season 26Season 27Season 28Season 29Season 30Season 31Season 32Season 33Season 34Season 35
Episodes
01: The Phantom02: The Bucket Hat Mystery03: The Prince, The Whiz Kid & The Millionaire04: A Perfect Spring Morning05: Deadly Mischief06: The Death of Dr. Schwartz07: The Trouble in Bardstown08: Running Man09: Raising the Dead10: The Ruse11: The Farmer's Wife12: The Trouble with Sarah13: Secrets in the Ashes14: Bringing Jay Home15: Malice16: The Professor & The Poet17: Take Two18: Savannah Speaks19: Temptation20: The Gorge21: Deadly Swagger22: Book of Lies23: A Window of Time24: Breaking Point25: In the Matter of Alex Murdaugh26: A Killing in Midtown27: Missing Ana28: Secrets Unmasked29: After the Flood30: The Bluegrass Mystery31: Slow Burn32: The Mushroom Mystery33: The Day Dee Disappeared34: Facing Ground Zero: A Dateline Special35: The Man Who Loved Christmas
